Faith and Control in a Fractured America

There is a tension inherent in religion that is rarely acknowledged by those who wield it most fervently. This same tension defines the cultural and political landscape of the United States we are experiencing today: a battle between faith and reason, doctrine and discovery, belief and the questioning spirit that drives understanding. At its best, religion has served as a means of making sense of the unknown, imposing order upon chaos, extracting meaning from suffering, and finding a path forward when all seems lost. However, in its institutionalized form, particularly in the American context, it has also become a tool of control.

The defining feature of this moment is not merely political polarization, nor is it just a crisis of governance. It is something deeper, something more existential. It is a battle for the meaning of truth itself. And in that battle, religion has been weaponized—not as a source of moral guidance, not as a personal framework for meaning, but as an instrument of power, used to justify the very hierarchies that spiritual traditions were often meant to challenge.

The Illusion of Moral Authority

To question religion, or rather, the political ideology shrouded in religious language that dominates specific segments of American discourse, is an act of defiance. This is why so many political and cultural leaders who claim to champion "faith" react so viscerally to dissent. They do not see faith as something to be tested, refined, and wrestled with in the fires of reason and experience. They see it as something to be enforced.

There is no more explicit example of this than the Christian nationalist movement that has embedded itself in American politics. Its adherents speak of morality, but their definition of morality is less about justice, compassion, or the ultimate love Jesus preached and more about submission—submission to a rigid social order, submission to authority, submission to a past that never truly existed, submission to their perversion of Christianity.

This movement thrives on a selective reading of scripture. It holds fast to many Old Testament laws of vengeance and tribal purity while ignoring the New Testament's call for love, mercy, and justice. It demands obedience to a set of moral codes that, upon closer inspection, bear more resemblance to the oppressive structures of empire than to anything resembling the teachings of Jesus. It is the paradox of modern American Christianity: a religion that preaches salvation but seems most invested in exclusion.

It is this version of faith that fuels so much of the reactionary and anti-democratic politics of the moment—anti-LGBTQ laws, abortion bans, the gutting of social programs, and the aggressive push to rewrite history in a way that erases systemic injustice. These are not policies rooted in the love-thy-neighbor philosophy preached by Jesus. They are policies rooted in fear, in hierarchy, in control.

A Manufactured Crisis of Meaning

What is happening in America today is not just political conflict—it is a crisis of meaning that is being manufactured and exploited. People seek stability during economic turmoil, social upheaval, and rapid technological change. They look for something unshakable and immutable to hold on to so they can push through. And for many, religion offers that stability, often not necessarily in its proper spiritual form but in its institutionalized, rule-based, authoritarian form.

The problem is that this kind of faith is brittle. It does not invite curiosity or growth; it demands obedience. And because it is rooted in control rather than connection, it must always find enemies—outsiders, sinners, intellectuals, activists, immigrants, LGBTQ people, and anyone who refuses to bow to its rigid order.

This is why we see an increase in moral panic, conspiratorial thinking, and an obsession with largely mythical "traditional values." It is not about faith; it is about control. It is about maintaining a particular social order that benefits those in power. And so the language of faith is co-opted...not to uplift or inspire, but to justify harm.

The Spiritual Crisis of a Nation and Faith

If America suffers from a crisis of meaning, what is the way forward?

Perhaps it begins with reclaiming faith, not in the sense of returning to dogma, but in rediscovering what faith should be: a pursuit of truth, a deep and abiding sense of love for others, and a radical rejection of fear-based control. Faith, in its truest form, should be the opposite of authoritarianism. It should embrace uncertainty, be committed to justice, and recognize that morality is not about rigid laws but about how we treat the most vulnerable among us. Any faith that demands unquestioning obedience at the expense of human dignity is no faith at all—it is a mechanism of power.

If there is a divine reality, it is not found in dogma, laws that criminalize bodily autonomy, or sermons by those who wield scripture like a weapon. It is found in the courage to ask the most challenging questions, the humility to recognize our biases and the crazy act of loving others, even those we do not understand.

This is where America stands today, at a crossroads between a faith that liberates and a faith that controls, between a faith that seeks truth and a faith that silences dissent, between a faith that embraces complexity and a faith that retreats into fear. The choice is not just about religion. It is about the future of a society that must decide whether it values conformity or conscience, whether it embraces the pursuit of justice or clings to the illusion of moral superiority.

For those who still believe that faith can be a force for good, the challenge is clear: reject the faith that serves empire and reclaim the faith that serves people. Anything less is surrender.

Please consider supporting my independent work at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/lorentcossette